Illuminate Me — artwork by Alan E. Kassan Illuminate Me · Alan E. Kassan
MetLife long-term disability appeals & litigation

MetLife denied or terminated your long-term disability benefits.

The letter is not the last word. What matters now is the reason MetLife actually gave, the policy definition that applies to the period in dispute, and the deadline for responding. Dorian Law represents claimants in ERISA disability appeals and federal litigation nationwide, and in state-law claims on individual MetLife policies.

Brent Dorian Brehm was counsel for the plaintiff in Leetzow v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, a 2016 federal court judgment against MetLife for a claimant whose migraines made reliable attendance impossible.

Free initial consultation. Most disability denial matters are handled on contingency; fees and expenses are explained before representation begins.

Start with the letter, not assumptions

What to do after a MetLife LTD denial

Keep the denial or termination letter and write down the date you received it. Request the governing policy or plan document and the claim file MetLife relied on, including every medical review, vocational report, and any surveillance or examination report. Then read the stated reason against the policy definition that applies to the period in dispute, which may differ from the definition that applied when benefits were first approved.

The appeal clock runs from receipt, not from the date printed on the letter. For an ERISA disability claim, the plan must give you at least 180 days following receipt of the adverse benefit determination to request review. 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i), (h)(4). Requesting the claim file does not extend that deadline.

If the deadline is close, obtain advice immediately about submitting a timely appeal and arranging any necessary supplementation. Do not miss the deadline while waiting for records or assume that a short appeal leaves unlimited time to add evidence. ERISA litigation generally focuses on the administrative record, although exceptions and the scope of review depend on governing law. The appeal is an important opportunity to document the claim before a final decision.

Dorian Law P.C. · Calabasas, California · Nationwide ERISA practice

Brent Dorian Brehm's MetLife disability experience

Brent Dorian Brehm represented the claimant in Leetzow v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company while practicing at Kantor & Kantor, before founding Dorian Law (docket and counsel of record, C.D. Cal. No. 5:15-cv-02468). The December 5, 2016 decision addressed whether recurring migraines prevented work with reasonable continuity during the policy's 180-day elimination period. Applying de novo review, the court evaluated the claimant's migraine log, medical history, treating-physician evidence, and attendance limitations. See ECF No. 36, pp. 19–23, 29–33. Read Brehm's biography and case experience.

The December 7, 2016 judgment ordered payment of disability benefits from the end of the elimination period through the following 24-month period, plus prejudgment interest and reasonable attorneys' fees and costs. The court remanded the claim for a determination under the policy's any-occupation standard.

That experience informs how Dorian Law evaluates variable conditions today. The evidence should describe episode frequency, duration, recovery time, and effects on attendance and sustained work. Brent Dorian Brehm has handled more than 750 insurance benefit disputes since 2006, including more than 300 ERISA and state-law matters at Kantor & Kantor with carriers including MetLife. ERISA and life, disability, and accidental death insurance denial litigation is the entirety of Dorian Law's practice; the firm represents claimants in MetLife LTD appeals and litigation nationwide.

  • Initial LTD denials and terminations after payment
  • Own-occupation to any-occupation transitions
  • Mental-nervous limitation applied to physical conditions
  • Paper-review denials of variable conditions
  • Denials that conflict with a Social Security award
  • Individual MetLife policies under state law
Six reasons MetLife gives, and what courts have required

Understand the reason in your MetLife letter

The examples below connect language reported in court opinions with the evidence and policy questions behind it. The Leetzow example also reflects Brehm's experience representing that claimant. Similar wording is a starting point for analysis, not proof that your policy or claim matches the cited case.

"The medical documentation failed to support a finding of restrictions or limitations"

A diagnosis and its effects on work are different questions. The response should address the actual evidentiary gap without accepting a demand for a test that cannot establish the condition.

"The medical documentation failed to support a finding of restrictions or limitations that would prevent [the claimant] from performing her own job, and therefore any gainful occupation."

MetLife final termination letter, June 10, 2015, as quoted in Seeman v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., No. 1:12-cv-498-GMS, mem. at 8 (D. Del. July 2018).

What MetLife is asserting
That the treating records do not translate the diagnosis into specific functional limits. For fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome, the reviewer's version was that no rheumatologic evaluation existed to measure impairment: "in the absence of any subsequent rheumatologic evaluations, it is difficult to determine what rheumatologic impairment, if any, currently exists."
What happened in the case
MetLife paid a Bank of America vice president's benefits for two years, then terminated them at the any-occupation change. After a 2013 remand, MetLife obtained paper reviews from three physicians, none of whom examined her, and instructed them that her appeal rights for CFS and fibromyalgia were exhausted. MetLife's own earlier reviewer, Dr. Louise Sheffield, had found the record supported physical limitations. The court held it is "an abuse of discretion for a plan administrator to demand objective tests establishing the existence of a condition for which there [are] no such tests," and granted summary judgment for the claimant with pre- and post-judgment interest.
What it does not establish
The court did not hold that symptom reports alone suffice. It relied on objective indicia of the symptoms: trigger-point findings by treating physicians and functional testing by a physical therapist. The decision applied the Third Circuit's arbitrary-and-capricious standard and a plan with a 60%-of-earnings any-occupation definition; a different circuit or definition changes the analysis.
Evidence that could matter
Documented tender-point or trigger-point examinations, physical-therapy or functional-capacity testing, a treating specialist's statement tying the symptoms to specific limits on sitting, standing, pace, and attendance, and a response to each reviewer's stated reason.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
We identify which reviewer's reasoning the letter adopts, what records that reviewer was given, and whether MetLife's own earlier reviewers reached a different conclusion. In Seeman, the court scrutinized MetLife's reliance on three paper reviews despite contrary evidence, including findings from its own earlier consultant and vocational evidence.

"There was never any evidence of that" — a reviewer rejects reported symptoms without examining you

A file review is not automatically improper. Examine whether the reviewer considered the reported limitations, explained any rejection, and received the relevant evidence.

"Although Dr. Osborne asserted that the claimant's needed narcotic medication caused cognitive side effects, there was never any evidence of that."

Report of MetLife independent physician consultant Dennis S. Gordan, M.D., as quoted in Demer v. IBM Corp. LTD Plan, 835 F.3d 893 (9th Cir. 2016), slip op. at 11.

What MetLife is asserting
That a file reviewer may treat a claimant's reported symptoms as unproven when they are not independently measured, even where the treating physician and a lay witness corroborate them.
What happened in the case
MetLife denied any-occupation benefits to an IBM auditor with documented cervical and lumbar spinal disease who took prescribed morphine. Two reviewers, neither of whom examined him, rejected the medication's cognitive effects. The Ninth Circuit held that the reviewers "had little basis for rejecting Mr. Demer's credibility," that they never explained why, and that MetLife abused its discretion. The court also held that the reviewers' financial relationship with MetLife — in 2009 and 2010, Dr. Elyssa Del Valle performed more than 250 reviews a year and earned more than $125,000 a year from MetLife, and Dr. Gordan performed 200–300 reviews and earned more than $175,000 a year — warranted skepticism of their conclusions.
What it does not establish
The court reversed and remanded to MetLife; it did not award benefits, because the record did not clearly establish entitlement. The financial-conflict holding gave the conflict "some, but not substantial, weight," drew a dissent from Judge Bybee, and its application outside the Ninth Circuit requires separate research. The claimant bore the burden of producing the compensation evidence. The figures describe 2009–2010 and are not a statement about either physician today.
Evidence that could matter
A treating physician's specific description of medication effects on concentration, memory, and pace; third-party statements from people who observe you; and, in litigation, discovery into how often and how much MetLife paid the reviewers it relied on.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
We request each reviewer's identity, specialty, report, and the questions MetLife asked them. If the questions or report omit cognitive limits, we investigate whether the review addressed them at all and submit evidence responsive to that gap.

"Sedentary to light level of physical exertion" — the vocational finding

Physical exertional capacity does not resolve every occupational requirement. Compare the vocational analysis with the policy definition and all documented limitations.

Even with the limitations its reviewer identified, the claimant "should be able to perform at the sedentary to light level of physical exertion as defined by the U.S. Department of Labor."

MetLife denial of any-occupation benefits, October 1, 2010, as described in Demer, slip op. at 8.

What MetLife is asserting
That exertional capacity answers the any-occupation question. The policy usually asks something narrower: whether you can perform a gainful occupation for which you are reasonably qualified, often with an earnings threshold. In Demer the threshold was $4,240.48 a month.
What happened in the cases
In Demer, MetLife never asked its vocational consultant to account for any cognitive limitation, so the occupations it identified — project director, computer security coordinator — assumed mental functioning the record contradicted. In Seeman, MetLife's in-house vocational analyst matched the claimant to a credit-and-collection manager job without considering fatigue or loss of concentration, while an outside vocational expert who met her for two hours found no physician had released her to her occupation. MetLife's final letter did not discuss either report.
What it does not establish
Courts regularly uphold sedentary findings where the medical record supports them. In both cases the vocational error followed from a medical review that omitted a category of limitation; a complete medical record with a sedentary finding is a harder case.
Evidence that could matter
A vocational assessment that addresses pace, attendance, concentration, and medication effects against the policy's actual definition and earnings threshold; records of your education and experience; and a comparison of the occupations MetLife named with your documented limits.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
We read the vocational report for its inputs, not its conclusion: which functional limits it was given, whether it addressed the earnings threshold, and whether it used the occupation as defined in the policy or a job title.

"Any condition that is not a Mental or Nervous Disorder" — the 24-month limitation

Analyze the occupation definition and the condition-specific limitation separately. The exact causal wording, exceptions, and governing law matter.

The claimant "has not demonstrated that she was unable to perform her own job and, therefore, any gainful occupation as of July 16, 2010, as a result of any condition that is not a Mental or Nervous Disorder or Disease."

MetLife final termination letter, June 10, 2015, as quoted in Seeman, mem. at 7–8.

What MetLife is asserting
That benefits beyond 24 months require proof of a disabling physical condition independent of any psychiatric diagnosis, and that the proof is lacking. An occupation-definition change may also apply, but its timing and requirements must be checked separately.
What happened in the cases
In Seeman, the court had already found in 2013 that the claimant met her burden on her physical conditions; it called MetLife's post-remand letter "inconsistent with the court's previous Memorandum and Order." In Demer, the plan changed from own-occupation to any-occupation after 12 months and separately limited mental/nervous benefits to 24 months. The disputed any-occupation review had to address physical disease and the effects of prescribed pain medication.
What it does not establish
Neither decision held the limitation unenforceable. The disputes required analysis of the evidence under the applicable disability definition, rather than treating a mental-health diagnosis as a complete answer. The exact wording of the limitation — "caused by," "contributed to by," or "primarily" — differs among MetLife plans and changes the analysis.
Evidence that could matter
Treating physicians describing the physical condition's limitations on their own terms, without routing them through the psychiatric diagnosis; objective findings for the physical condition; and a statement addressing which condition would be disabling if the other were absent.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
We identify the limitation's causal wording, exceptions, applicable dates, and governing law. We then assess the evidence under both the disability definition and the limitation, including how the conditions interact and whether either is independently disabling.

A denial that does not address your Social Security disability award

An SSA award is not automatically controlling, but applicable ERISA disability rules require an explanation of disagreement with an award presented to the plan.

Facts from Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Glenn, 554 U.S. 105 (2008).

What MetLife is asserting
A letter may disagree with, distinguish, or fail to address the SSA decision. Identify the explanation actually given and whether MetLife had the award and underlying evidence.
What happened in the case
MetLife, administering and insuring a Sears plan, encouraged the claimant to apply for Social Security disability, received the benefit of the offset when she won, and then concluded she could do sedentary work without addressing the agency's contrary finding. The Supreme Court held that MetLife's dual role as decision-maker and payer is a conflict of interest courts must weigh as a factor in abuse-of-discretion review, and affirmed the Sixth Circuit's decision setting aside the denial, counting the treatment of the SSDI award among the circumstances that made the denial unreasonable.
What it does not establish
An SSDI award does not bind MetLife; the standards differ. The conflict is a factor whose weight depends on the circumstances, not a change in the standard of review. And the inference runs both ways: in Demer, the Ninth Circuit found no error in treating a Social Security denial as evidence that MetLife's review was objective.
Evidence that could matter
The SSA decision and the medical evidence it relied on, placed in MetLife's record with a request that MetLife explain any disagreement before its final decision.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
We submit the SSA determination and relevant supporting evidence and compare MetLife's explanation with the applicable rules. For disability claims filed after April 1, 2018, 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(g)(1)(vii)(A)(iii) and (j)(6)(i)(C) require an explanation of the basis for disagreeing with or not following an SSA disability determination presented to the plan. Any conflict analysis is a separate, fact-specific question.

Migraines, incomplete symptom logs, and reliable attendance

A normal examination between episodes or an incomplete time entry may leave the real issue unanswered: can the claimant sustain work with the continuity the policy requires?

“claimant reported no disability hours during these months although headaches were reported.”

Excerpt from the report of Dr. Diane Wolf, MetLife’s independent physician consultant, quoted in Leetzow v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, ECF No. 36, p. 31 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 5, 2016). Brehm represented the claimant before founding Dorian Law.

What MetLife argued
MetLife’s litigation brief relied on only seven recorded disability hours during the 180-day elimination period. Its reviewers also cited normal examination findings and gaps in the log’s disability-hour entries. See pp. 18, 21, 23, 31.
What the court found
The log documented migraines on 43 days, and the claimant explained that each caused some disability. The court considered those explanations alongside treatment history, physician statements, and work absences. It treated absenteeism as strong evidence and found that migraines prevented performance of occupational duties with reasonable continuity. See pp. 23–24, 29–33.
Limits of the decision
The court applied de novo review to this policy and record. It did not establish a universal number of migraine days or absences that proves disability. The any-occupation period was remanded rather than decided. See pp. 19–20, 33–38.
Evidence that could matter
Contemporaneous logs recording frequency, duration, recovery, and work disruption; treating-physician explanations; employer attendance and leave records; and corroborating observations. Identify retrospective explanations accurately and explain their basis.
How Dorian Law evaluates it
Drawing on Brehm’s experience in Leetzow, we compare the reviewer’s reading of a log with the underlying entries and other evidence. We investigate missing information and document actual limitations, then address how recurring episodes affect the work schedule and the policy’s applicable definition.
The Litigation Back Approach

How Dorian Law builds the response

Dorian Law's Litigation Back Approach considers what would be needed to resolve the disputed issue in court and works backward to the current claim or appeal. The strategy adapts as evidence develops or MetLife changes its reasoning: document the facts, preserve pertinent arguments, and create opportunities for payment or a stronger later challenge.

  1. Identify who pays and which definition controls

    Confirm whether MetLife insures the plan or only administers an employer-funded one, which disability definition applies to the disputed period, whether a condition-specific limitation is in play, and the exact wording of each. The Glenn analysis and the 24-month analysis both depend on these answers.

  2. Get the claim file and name the reviewers

    Request the complete claim file under 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), including each reviewing physician's identity, specialty, report, the records they were given, and the questions MetLife asked them. In Seeman, the instruction MetLife gave its reviewers was itself part of the court's reasoning.

  3. Have treating physicians answer the reviewer, not restate the diagnosis

    A useful physician statement gives specific functional limits, explains the basis for them, and responds to each point the MetLife consultant made. For variable conditions it addresses attendance and sustainability directly.

  4. Match the vocational analysis to the actual definition

    Where MetLife's vocational report relies on exertional capacity alone, address pace, concentration, attendance, medication effects, and any earnings threshold. Where a Social Security award exists, put it in the record and ask MetLife to explain any disagreement.

  5. Respond to new evidence before the final decision

    For ERISA disability appeals subject to these rules, MetLife must provide new or additional evidence, and any new or additional rationale supporting an adverse appeal decision, free of charge and sufficiently in advance to allow a reasonable response. 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(4)(i)–(ii). If litigation follows, the standard of review, forum, and claim are evaluated on the record this process produced.

Deadlines and governing law for a MetLife claim

DeadlineRuleWhere it comes from
180 daysYour time to appeal an ERISA disability denial, counted from receipt of the adverse determination. A plan may allow more; it may not allow less.29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i), (h)(4)
45 + 45 daysFor an ERISA disability appeal, generally 45 days, with one extension of up to 45 days for special circumstances and timely notice explaining the extension. Certain requests for necessary claimant information can toll the period; check the actual timeline.29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(i)(3)(i)
Contract + lawReview any contractual suit limitation and applicable law. A reasonable contractual period may be enforceable and can begin before the appeal ends. If no enforceable contractual period applies, courts generally borrow an applicable state limitations period. Do not assume the deadline runs from the final denial.Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Ins. Co., 571 U.S. 99 (2013)

Employer group coverage (ERISA)

Most private-employer LTD plans are governed by ERISA. The internal appeal is generally required before suit, a federal judge decides the case without a jury, and the court usually reviews the record MetLife had when it decided. Relief is generally the benefits owed, interest, and attorneys' fees; punitive and emotional-distress damages are not available. Governmental plans and qualifying church plans are generally exempt, although coverage must be assessed for the actual arrangement.

Individual MetLife policies (state law)

MetLife stopped selling individual disability policies through agents on March 6, 2017, but continues to administer the policies already in force (MetLife). Those claims are governed by the policy and state law. In California that can mean a jury, discovery into claims handling, and bad-faith remedies beyond the policy benefit.

The conflict of interest, stated accurately

What Glenn does and does not do

When MetLife both evaluates a claim and pays it from its own funds, the dual role is a conflict of interest a court must weigh as one factor in deciding whether MetLife abused its discretion. The weight depends on the circumstances. It does not convert review to de novo, and it does not make every denial wrong. When MetLife administers an employer-funded plan, do not assume the same insurer/payor dual-role conflict; examine who decides, who pays, and the relevant financial arrangements. The conflict can also exist at the reviewer level even where MetLife has walled off its claims staff, which is what Demer held about MetLife's paid consultants. In states that prohibit discretionary clauses in insured disability policies — California, under Insurance Code § 10110.6 — the court may review the denial without deference at all.

A treating physician's opinion is not automatically controlling. Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord, 538 U.S. 822 (2003), rejected a treating-physician rule under ERISA while holding that an administrator may not arbitrarily refuse to credit reliable evidence. The appeal has to show why the evidence is reliable, not assume it will be credited.

If a deadline may already have passed, have the notice reviewed before concluding nothing can be done. Whether a late appeal is excused, or a limitations period was adequately disclosed, depends on the plan language and governing circuit law.

Direct answers

MetLife disability denial questions

What should I do after MetLife denies or terminates my LTD benefits?

Keep the denial letter and record the date you received it. Identify the appeal deadline, request the policy or plan documents and the complete claim file, and address each stated reason for denial with evidence. For an ERISA claim, the administrative appeal is the main opportunity to build the record a court will later review. Dorian Law evaluates the denial, the policy language, the medical evidence, and the occupational requirements before recommending a strategy.

How long do I have to appeal a MetLife long-term disability denial?

For a disability claim governed by ERISA, the plan must give you at least 180 days following receipt of the adverse benefit determination to request review (29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i), (h)(4)). A plan may allow longer. The lawsuit deadline is separate. Review any contractual limitation and applicable law; Heimeshoff v. Hartford explains that an enforceable contractual period can begin before the appeal concludes.

Has Brent Dorian Brehm represented a claimant against MetLife?

Yes. In Leetzow v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, No. EDCV 15-2468-VAP (C.D. Cal.), Brent Dorian Brehm represented a claimant disabled by chronic migraines. The December 7, 2016 judgment ordered MetLife to pay benefits from the end of the elimination period through the 24-month own-occupation period, plus prejudgment interest and attorneys' fees and costs, and remanded the claim for an any-occupation determination. Brehm handled the case at Kantor & Kantor before founding Dorian Law. The judgment does not predict the outcome of any other claim.

Does MetLife v. Glenn mean my denial must be overturned?

No. Glenn holds that when MetLife both decides claims and pays them from its own funds, that dual role is a conflict of interest the court must weigh as a factor in abuse-of-discretion review. How much weight depends on the circumstances. It does not automatically invalidate a denial or change the standard to de novo review, and it applies differently when MetLife only administers an employer-funded plan.

Can MetLife rely on a doctor who never examined me?

ERISA allows file reviews, but courts examine how they were used. In Demer v. IBM Corp. LTD Plan, the Ninth Circuit found that two MetLife consultants who, in 2009 and 2010, performed hundreds of reviews or addenda annually for MetLife and received substantial compensation from that work had a financial conflict warranting skepticism, and that rejecting the claimant's reported medication side effects without examining him or explaining why was an abuse of discretion. A useful response from your treating physician addresses the reviewer's specific reasoning rather than restating the diagnosis.

What if MetLife says there is no objective evidence of my fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue?

In Seeman v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, No. 1:12-cv-498 (D. Del.), the court held it is an abuse of discretion for a plan administrator to demand objective tests establishing a condition for which no such tests exist. MetLife had terminated benefits for fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome after three consultants reviewed the file without examining the claimant; the court granted summary judgment for her in 2018 with interest. The record still needs to document functional limits: trigger-point findings, consistent treatment, and specific limits on sitting, standing, pace, and attendance.

Can MetLife stop my benefits after 24 months?

Depending on the policy and the evidence, yes. Two separate provisions can apply at that point: a change in the disability definition from own occupation to any occupation, and a limitation on benefits for mental or nervous conditions. They are analyzed separately, and the limitation's exact wording differs among plans. The evidence must address each applicable provision and its exceptions. Independent physical disability may matter, but the causal wording and governing law determine its significance. Submit responsive evidence during the claim or appeal rather than assuming it can be added later in court.

What if MetLife says I can do sedentary work?

The policy definition controls, and the ability to sit or lift a small amount does not answer whether you can sustain the work MetLife's vocational analyst identified. In Seeman, MetLife's analyst matched the claimant to a manager job without considering fatigue or loss of concentration; in Demer, MetLife never asked its vocational consultant to account for the cognitive effects of prescribed narcotics. Pace, attendance, concentration, medication effects, education and experience, and any earnings threshold in the policy are all part of the analysis.

What if MetLife ignores my Social Security disability award?

An SSDI award does not bind MetLife, because the standards differ. But in MetLife v. Glenn the Supreme Court counted it against MetLife that the company encouraged the claimant to seek SSDI, took the offset when she was approved, and then denied her LTD claim without addressing the agency's finding. Present the SSA determination and relevant supporting evidence to MetLife. For disability claims filed after April 1, 2018, applicable ERISA regulations require an explanation of the basis for disagreeing with or not following an SSA disability determination presented to the plan. Assess the explanation against both the policy and the record.

What should I do if MetLife schedules an IME or uses surveillance?

Review the policy and the examination notice promptly and do not ignore the request; failure to cooperate can affect benefits. Raise specialty, scope, travel, and accommodation issues before the examination, be accurate about symptoms and activity, and request a copy of the report. For surveillance, the question is whether what was filmed is inconsistent with the limitations actually claimed, including frequency, duration, and recovery time.

Does leaving my job mean I have to convert my MetLife LTD coverage?

Not necessarily. A claim for a disability that began while coverage was in force is a different question from converting coverage for a future disability. MetLife's published LTD conversion packet requires the application within 31 days of the date employment ends and lists among its conditions that the applicant is not disabled and was insured for at least 12 months. If you are already disabled, assess rights under the existing group policy separately from any conversion or portability option, using the terms applicable to your coverage.

Does Dorian Law handle MetLife appeals and lawsuits outside California?

Yes. Dorian Law is based in Calabasas, California and represents claimants in ERISA disability appeals and federal litigation nationwide. Forum, governing circuit law, and court admission requirements are evaluated for each matter. State-law claims on individual policies require a separate assessment.

What does it cost to have Dorian Law review a MetLife denial?

The initial consultation is free. Most disability denial matters are handled on contingency, with no attorneys' fees unless there is a recovery. The fee agreement explains the percentage, treatment of any court-awarded fees, responsibility for expenses, and any alternative arrangement before representation begins.

Sources and MetLife decisions cited on this page

Links below identify the merits opinions and judgment supporting the case descriptions. Brehm's biography provides additional information about his experience. Supporting authorities are not presented as matters handled by Dorian Law.

CaseCourt · YearReview or procedureOutcome
Leetzow v. MetLifeC.D. Cal. · 2016De novo; bench trial on the papers (ECF No. 36, p. 19)Judgment for claimant through the own-occupation period, interest, fees and costs; remand for any-occupation determination. Brent Dorian Brehm, counsel for plaintiff.
MetLife v. GlennU.S. Supreme Court · 2008Abuse of discretion, conflict weighedDenial set aside; dual-role conflict is a factor in review
Demer v. IBM Corp. LTD Plan9th Cir. · 2016Abuse of discretion with skepticismReversed and remanded to MetLife; no benefits award
Seeman v. MetLifeD. Del. · 2013, 2018Arbitrary and capriciousRemanded in 2013; summary judgment for claimant with interest in 2018
  1. Leetzow v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, No. EDCV 15-2468-VAP (KKx), ECF No. 36, 2016 WL 7324092 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 5, 2016). De novo review: pp. 19–20; objective-evidence and symptom-log arguments: pp. 21–24; attendance and reasonable continuity: pp. 29–33; scope of relief and remand: pp. 33–38. Separate judgment, ECF No. 37 (Dec. 7, 2016). Counsel of record: docket, CourtListener RECAP Archive (Brent Dorian Brehm, attorney for plaintiff).
  2. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Glenn, 554 U.S. 105 (2008). Dual-role conflict as a factor in abuse-of-discretion review.
  3. Demer v. IBM Corp. LTD Plan, 835 F.3d 893 (9th Cir. 2016). Financial conflict of MetLife's paid consultants; medication side effects; reviewer compensation figures for 2009–2010. Supporting authority, not a Dorian Law matter.
  4. Seeman v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., No. 1:12-cv-498-GMS (D. Del. July 2018) (memorandum and order granting summary judgment after 2013 remand). Source of the quoted MetLife letter language. Supporting authority, not a Dorian Law matter.
  5. Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord, 538 U.S. 822 (2003). Treating-physician opinions under ERISA.
  6. Heimeshoff v. Hartford Life & Accident Ins. Co., 571 U.S. 99 (2013). Enforceability of a plan's contractual limitations period.
  7. 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1, subsections (g)(1)(vii)(A), (h)(2)(iii), (h)(3)(i), (h)(4), (i)(3)–(4), and (j)(6)(i). Appeal timing, relevant records, new evidence, decision deadlines, and explanations of disagreement with evidence or SSA determinations; applicability depends on the claim date and arrangement.
  8. MetLife, Individual Disability Insurance (current customers). Statement that MetLife no longer sells individual disability policies through agents as of March 6, 2017.
  9. MetLife, How to Apply for Long Term Disability Conversion Insurance (form rev. 05/22). 31-day application window and eligibility conditions.

Tell us why MetLife said no.

Send the denial or termination letter and the date you received it. If you have them, add the policy or summary plan description, any appeal decision, and anything MetLife has already sent from the claim file. The initial review identifies the stated reason, the definition that applies, the deadline, and whether the file supports an appeal, a lawsuit, or both. Missing documents are not a reason to wait, especially with an appeal deadline running.

Free initial consultation. Most disability denial matters are handled on contingency; fees and expenses are explained before representation begins.

Attorney advertising. This page provides general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Policy terms, governing law, deadlines, and available remedies vary. Past results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes. The Leetzow matter was handled by Brent Dorian Brehm before Dorian Law P.C. was founded. Demer and Seeman are cited as published authority; neither was handled by Dorian Law or Brehm. Quotations attributed to MetLife or its reviewers are taken from court opinions and describe the specific case and period identified; they are not characterizations of any person or company today.