Your AD&D Claim Was Denied? Insurers Are Counting on You Not Fighting Back.
Dorian Law's attorneys have spent years challenging insurers' "not an accident" arguments, dismantling exclusion defenses, and winning benefits for families who were told no. This page covers what AD&D insurance is, how claims get denied, and what your options are.
On This Page
When an insurance company denies an AD&D claim, one thing they're counting on is that you won't know how to fight back. This page covers what AD&D insurance is, how claims get denied, and what your options are. If something here sounds familiar, we'd like to hear from you.
Most people fighting a denial focus only on the appeal. Dorian Law starts at the other end. Before we write a single letter, we ask: what would we need to prove in court to win? That question shapes everything — the evidence we gather, the arguments we make, and the record we build from day one. We call this the Litigation Back Approach, and it works across every type of AD&D claim, whether your policy is through an employer or purchased individually.
"Brent was knowledgeable, thoughtful and had a strategic approach. I will never be able to properly thank Brent enough for helping me reach a positive outcome."
— Erin E.What Is Accidental Death & Dismemberment (AD&D) Insurance?
AD&D insurance is a type of policy that pays benefits if death or dismemberment of the insured results directly and solely from an accident. It's often offered as a supplement to life insurance and health insurance, or as a standalone policy. Unlike life insurance, which pays out for death from almost any cause — illness, natural causes, accidents — AD&D specifically focuses on accidental events.
Accidental Death
The policy pays a benefit to your designated beneficiary if you die as a result of a covered accident.
Dismemberment
Typically refers to the loss, or loss of use, of limbs — arms, legs, hands, feet — as well as loss of sight, hearing, or speech. The specific definition is detailed in your policy documents.
Common Reasons AD&D Claims Are Denied — and How Dorian Law Can Help
It can be incredibly disheartening to have an AD&D claim denied, especially when you believe you're rightfully entitled to benefits. Here are the reasons insurers deny AD&D claims most often, and how we answer each one.
"Not an Accident" Argument
Insurers may argue the event doesn't meet the policy's definition of "accident," classifying it instead as illness, natural cause, or a foreseeable injury. We investigate the circumstances and build the case to demonstrate the accidental nature of the event.
Application of Exclusions
Insurers often apply exclusions broadly, even when the facts may not clearly fall within the exclusion's intended scope. We analyze the policy language and challenge ambiguous or overreaching interpretations.
Pre-Existing Condition Allegations
Even when the death or dismemberment was accidental, insurers may claim a pre-existing condition was a significant contributing factor. We work with medical experts to demonstrate the accident was the primary cause.
Insufficient Proof of Accident
Claimants bear the burden of proving the death or dismemberment was accidental. We gather police reports, witness statements, medical records, and expert opinions to build a compelling case.
Policy Interpretation Disputes
AD&D policy language can be complex and open to interpretation. We identify ambiguities and advocate for a fair, claimant-favorable reading.
What Does AD&D Insurance Cover?
Coverage details vary by policy, but for a claim to succeed, the death or dismemberment must be directly caused by an accident — meaning the accident must be the primary and overriding cause, and other factors like pre-existing health conditions should not be the substantial contributing cause. Covered accidents commonly include:
Motor Vehicle Accidents
Car crashes, motorcycle accidents, pedestrian accidents.
Falls
Serious falls resulting in death or dismemberment.
Workplace Accidents
Depending on policy specifics and whether workers' compensation applies.
Exposure to the Elements
Death or dismemberment from hypothermia, heatstroke, or other environmental factors.
Accidental Injuries from Objects
Being struck by falling objects, machinery accidents, and similar events.
Transportation Accidents
Accidents involving planes, trains, boats, or other public transportation.
Group vs. Individual AD&D Policies
Understanding which type of policy you have is a critical first step, especially when making a claim. Group policies, in particular, most often fall under ERISA, which changes your deadlines and remedies.
Group AD&D Policies
- Obtained through employment, associations, or memberships.
- Generally less expensive — risk is spread across a larger group.
- Coverage amounts and terms are often pre-determined with less flexibility.
- Policy language can be more restrictive and harder to interpret.
- Portability is often limited; coverage may end with employment.
Individual AD&D Policies
- Purchased directly by an individual from an insurer.
- Typically more expensive due to individualized risk assessment.
- Greater flexibility in coverage amounts, beneficiaries, and terms.
- Policy language is often more straightforward — a direct contract.
- Portable — coverage remains as long as premiums are paid.
Common Exclusions in AD&D Insurance Policies
AD&D policies contain exclusions — specific circumstances that are not covered — and they're frequently the basis for claim denials. Common exclusions include:
Illness & Disease
Death or dismemberment caused by illness or medical condition, even if sudden, is almost always excluded.
Suicide & Self-Inflicted Injury
Intentional self-harm is explicitly excluded.
Pre-Existing Conditions
Excluded if a pre-existing condition significantly contributed to the accident or injury.
Mental or Nervous Disorders
Typically not covered as a cause of death or dismemberment.
Drug & Alcohol Involvement
Often excluded, though specifics vary by policy and intoxication level.
War & Acts of Terrorism
Declared or undeclared, generally excluded.
Active Military Duty
Some policies exclude or limit coverage while on active duty.
Risky Activities
Extreme sports, skydiving, racing — definitions of "risky" vary by policy.
Medical Treatment / Surgery
Complications from treatment or diagnostic procedures may be excluded.
Criminal Activity
Excluded if the accident occurs while committing or attempting a crime.
Understanding these exclusions — and who carries the burden of proof — is paramount. We meticulously review policy language and challenge unfair or overly broad exclusion interpretations.
Browse by Insurance Company
Denial tactics vary by carrier. We've built out carrier-specific pages as our AD&D case experience with each insurer has grown.
Don't see your insurer listed? We handle AD&D denials against every major carrier nationwide — contact us and we'll tell you what to expect from yours specifically.
FAQs About Accidental Death & Dismemberment Insurance
AD&D insurance provides financial protection if death or serious injury — dismemberment — happens solely and directly because of an accident. Unlike standard life insurance, which covers death from most causes, AD&D is focused specifically on accidents. Dismemberment isn't just losing a limb; it also includes loss of use of limbs, sight, hearing, or speech.
Common examples include car crashes, serious falls, workplace incidents, injuries from severe weather exposure, accidents involving objects, and transportation accidents like plane or train mishaps. For a claim to be approved, the death or dismemberment must be a direct result of the accident.
Yes. Common exclusions include death or injury from illness, suicide, pre-existing health conditions, mental health issues, drug or alcohol-related incidents, war, risky activities, and complications from medical treatment. Insurers sometimes apply these exclusions very strictly, and we regularly challenge unfair interpretations of them.
Not necessarily, but it's worth talking with an experienced attorney to help you decide. Insurers often deny claims by arguing the incident wasn't truly an "accident," citing exclusions, claiming pre-existing conditions were involved, or disputing the sufficiency of proof. An attorney who understands these tactics can help you determine the strongest path forward.
Most group AD&D policies obtained through an employer are governed by ERISA, which sets specific appeal deadlines and remedies. Individual policies purchased directly from an insurer typically are not. We determine which applies to your policy early, since it shapes the entire strategy.
Meet the Author
Let Us Be Your Champions
If you're considering an AD&D claim, or your claim has already been denied, don't hesitate to reach out. Based in Los Angeles and handling AD&D cases nationwide, we're here to answer your questions and evaluate your situation. The consultation is free and confidential.